Lead and Crime

Over the weekend, the Washington Post published an article suggesting that much of the decline in crime in the 1990s may have been due to the reduction of childhood lead exposure after the removal of lead from gasoline and house paint.

This is an intriguing hypothesis. There is evidence on an individual level that high exposure to lead is harmful to both IQ and the ability to delay gratification, two traits that could enhance the attractiveness of crime. There is also some suggestive time-series evidence of a relationship: the rise and fall in lead exposure at the national level match the rise and fall in crime. Still, although both Post reporter Shankar Vendantam and the cited economist, Rick Nevin (whom I’d never heard of), appear quite convinced by the time-series data, I am not. When you have a variable like crime that goes up for a long time then goes down for a long time, it is easy to find other variables that share that pattern and appear to have a causal impact, even though the relationship is completely spurious.

About seven years ago, Michael Greenstone and I tried to look into this same issue using airborne lead measures at the local level, as well as other approaches. We ultimately gave up without finding anything. That largely soured me on the lead/crime link.

Recently, however, Jessica Wolpaw Reyes at Amherst has put together what appears to me to be the most persuasive evidence to date in favor of a relationship between lead and crime. Rather than looking at a national time-series, she tries to exploit differences in the rates at which lead was removed from gasoline across states. I haven’t read her paper with the care that a referee would at an academic journal; but, at least superficially, what she is doing looks pretty sensible. She finds that lead has big effects (and, for what it’s worth, she also confirms that, when controlling for lead, the link between abortion and crime is as strong or stronger as in our initial study, which did not control for lead.)

Roger Masters, a professor at Dartmouth, has also been doing interesting research on this subject, although I am also not very familiar with his work.

It will be very interesting to see how this research agenda plays out. If it can be shown here and in other areas that environmental factors have powerful and long-lasting impacts on human behavior, it may dramatically change the way we think about public policy.


BruceKeener

Interesting post.

I think it begs the question of what can be done about the effects of lead exposure. Can those who grew up around lead paint, as I did, do anything to overcome its effects (such as the delayed gratification problem, which I have in spades).

angelofthenorth

it would be intriguing to see if there's a 'lead map' for housing in the UK.

Certainly the house I grew up in was public-owned housing, and there was a great effort to strip out the lead in the house, but friends in houses from the same era weren't so lucky.

I'm especially curious about whether toxic chemicals that are released by flooding will have long-term effects on crime rates.

110phil

Is there existing scientific evidence that lead in gasoline somehow works its way into children?

egretman

Only if they inhale.

prosa

New York has among the worst lead paint problem of any large city on account of its older housing stock. Yet it's also had among the biggest declines in crime rates.

frankenduf

I'm with 110phil- why not simply correlate blood levels of lead and criminal behavior?

pparkman

Now that crime rates are moving back up, should we infer that lead is getting back into the food chain (or air supply)? Or perhaps there are other reasons more in line with what used to be the conventional wisdom?

suntzusjb

Lead in the plumbing has been cited as a probable cause of the decline and fall of Rome.

Maybe somebody should do a study on those kids who bought the Thomas the Tank Engine toys (made in China with lead paint).

kah

Very interesting post.

What about birth control pills in the common water supply?

It would be very ironic if some women spend time and energy to reduce hormones in cattle and other farm animals, but then choose a birth control method for themselves that pollutes our environment just as much.

kah

prosa, a main point in the linked article is that the crime decline in NY followed a previous reduction in lead paint.

Sure, not all the lead was removed during that lead reduction. Sure, as a result NY still has a bad lead problem. But hey, there's still a little crime in NY now and then, too.

stevesliva

Maybe unleaded paint is causing a rise in autism, too.

Or the cause could be the decline in mothers smoking during pregnancy.

Really, though, I think the answer is the microwave oven.

liberalarts

frankenduf: I think that elevated lead levels in the bloodstream permanently cause the IQ problems. However, after exposure is reduced, the blood concentrations fall. Thus, if lead causes an increased propensity for crime, criminals may test at low levels if they are no longer in the high lead environment.

keeprollin41

To pparkman, too many confounding factors exist for one to make a claim that a rise in crime is a reaction to a rise in lead...If we could hold for all other confounding factors, this argument could get much more interesting...

billpg

Counter Factor? Has there been an assessment on the effects of selective breeding (sperm banks and egg donation) on IQ? The impact should be visible as rising national IQs, above the standard distribution beginning around 140. Nothing to do with lead, but maybe we will have smarter criminals.

Susi Rankis

I guess there are a couple things to consider, the first being that most urban places that still contain high levels of lead are in poor areas which would automatically drive crime levels up

second, that you have to distinguish between petty crime, white collar, violent .... etc. Most crime happens when the criminal is between 15-25ish, although not sure about white collar crime.

lead exposure at a young age - can cause permanent damage to the nervous system, whether or not lead levels are present in blood later in life... Part of the affects of lead exposure can decrease your ability to make decisions or correct judgements, soooo..... I would be interested in finding out if there is correlation in crime & lead and how someone reacts to a situation... Do they understand crime can have penalties and to what extent? Do they react in a violent or aggressive manner if things don't go their way? Can lead exposure decrease the amount of time or level of "bull***t" they can handle...which makes them "snap" and commit a violent crime?

also... dont forget about all of the other toxins in the environment...what is their contribution, and can there be multiple attributes to increased violent behavior?

Read more...

R.J.

Billpg has a very uneducated view or both the goals and methods of 3rd party assisted reproduction.

Firstly, all breeding by humans is "selective" unless they are quite drunk, which admitted is not uncommon. Woemen, especially uper and middle class women tend to look for a good looking man with promising job prospects.

Secondly, sprem donors are selected by U.S. banks for these characteristics: high motile sperm counts, freedom from common genetic diseases, general good health, heterosexuality (don't ask me why), attendance at a well regarded university, and physical beauty.

Women, mostly of the middle to upper classes, then select from these men based on those charateristics. If you think the average student at a highly regarded university has an IQ of 140 or higher, I invite you to spend some time with a few of these. They do, however have excellant job prospects.

The whole thing is kind of a wash. Its not about super babies. Its about allowing women who aren't able to reproduce with there partner to feel comfortable that the donor is "one of us."

Read more...

BruceKeener

Interesting post.

I think it begs the question of what can be done about the effects of lead exposure. Can those who grew up around lead paint, as I did, do anything to overcome its effects (such as the delayed gratification problem, which I have in spades).

angelofthenorth

it would be intriguing to see if there's a 'lead map' for housing in the UK.

Certainly the house I grew up in was public-owned housing, and there was a great effort to strip out the lead in the house, but friends in houses from the same era weren't so lucky.

I'm especially curious about whether toxic chemicals that are released by flooding will have long-term effects on crime rates.

110phil

Is there existing scientific evidence that lead in gasoline somehow works its way into children?

egretman

Only if they inhale.