When Crowds Panic

Jeff Wise Jeff Wise

Jeff Wise, the author of Extreme Fear: The Science of Your Mind in Danger, guest-blogged for us earlier this year about road fear. This time, he turns his attention to another interesting phenomenon: crowd panic.

When Crowds Panic
By Jeff Wise

The recent deaths at the annual Love Parade music festival in Duisburg, Germany, can be counted among the most perplexing form of tragedy: one that unfolds entirely as a result of the normal psychology of healthy human beings. When crowds reach a critical density, they automatically become vulnerable to a contagion of blind fear that overwhelms any attempt at rational behavior. The paradox of terror is that the subconscious fear response, which evolved over millions of years to keep us safe, can itself pose a terrible danger in the 21st century. If anything, the advent of modern technology seems to have left us even more vulnerable to fatal stampedes, as mass transportation and instant communication make it easier to bring large crowds together.

The toll in human lives can be immense: in the past decade there have been more than 100 stampede events resulting in mass fatalities, with the worst, Iraq’s Baghdad Bridge stampede in 2005, killing nearly 1,000 people. Just as a forest fire needs a critical density of dry timber in order to reach the blowout stage, a crowd must reach a critical density in order to become dangerous. Crowds will continue to grow in size or density until there are about 10 people per square meter – that’s 2,600 people in an area the size of a tennis court.

What happens next has been examined in a fascinating pair of recent papers by Ed Hsu and colleagues at Johns Hopkins. According to Hsu et al., there are two major ways that things can go wrong. One is a “turbulent stampede” that takes place when two crowds merge from different directions or a stationary crowd is induced to panic. The other, a “unidirectional stampede,” occurs when a crowd reacts to a sudden positive or negative change in force. A positive change in force might occur when a crowd is stopped by a barricade or a narrowing in a passageway; a negative force is the release of constraining pressure, as for instance might occur when a gate is opened. Based on preliminary accounts, the deaths that occurred at Duisburg were a result of a positive force that occurred when security guards shut a gate at the end of a tunnel.

Once panic takes hold, individual free will goes out the window and the mass as a whole becomes subject to a collective crowd psychology. Not only do people in such situations show a tendency to mimic the behavior of those around them, but the sheer physical force of the crowd can become irresistible, capable of bending sturdy steel stanchions and knocking down brick walls. One particularly gruesome aspect of stampedes is that these factors can cause victims to overlook perfectly good exits, as for instance occurred in the Station nightclub fire in Rhode Island in 2001.

People tend to die standing up. When the pushing stops and the bodies covering them are removed, they tend to remain standing. The proximate cause of death is pressure applied to their bodies in a front to back direction, causing “ventilatory failure.” When the pressure is applied to their sides, they often survive, presumably because their rib cages are still able to expand and draw breath.

The deadliest single event is the pilgrimage to Mecca, particularly the “stoning the devil” event, which can draw crowds of up to 3 million people. Lethal stampedes occurred in 1990, 1994, 2004, and 2006.

For years, as Hsu et al point out, engineers and psychologists have been working to model crowd behavior and to figure out how to design spaces so that stampedes are prevented. Yet every year lethal stampedes become more common. In the ’80s, there were 24 incidents reported in the media; in the ’90s,? 62; in the 2000s, up to 2007, there were 129.

What should you do if you find yourself in a potential stampede situation? Once the panic has begun, very little, due to the enormous forces at work. Your best bet is to stay alert whenever in a large crowd. Take note of exits and other escape routes, and when the density becomes high enough to seem dangerous, move away from the center. Ask yourself: do I really need to be here? Perhaps the greatest irony of stampedes is that, in retrospect, the attraction that brought the crowd together seldom seems important enough to merit any deaths at all.


Nonchalant Savant

"When crowds reach a critical density, they automatically become vulnerable to a contagion of blind fear that overwhelms any attempt at rational behavior."

Sounds like Wall Street on any given day...

Sam

"Perhaps the greatest irony of stampedes is that, in retrospect, the attraction that brought the crowd together seldom seems important enough to merit any deaths at all." Seldom? What attractions are important enough to merit deaths?

Dan

"Perhaps the greatest irony of stampedes is that, in retrospect, the attraction that brought the crowd together seldom seems important enough to merit any deaths at all."

Kinda of a weird way to close, considering he was just discussing the pilgrimage to Mecca a couple paragraphs before.

Matt

"The paradox of terror is that the subconscious fear response, which evolved over millions of years to keep us safe, can itself pose a terrible danger in the 21st century."

That's an interesting assessment. Are there other examples of "hijacked" adaptations within the evolutionary process, that now actually harm us? And are we to assume that with enough time (another couple of million years?) we will, through survival of the fittest/better kinds of adaptations, over come all of these?

David L

I'm no expert but it seems to me like drop-and-cover would work--IF you could get down before the pressure of the crowd pinned you in place. Since people are topheavy (i.e., higher mass/height ratio in the chest than in the legs), there would be a lot more empty space toward the floor.

Of course if you did that, others would likely trip and tumble over you and they would be more likely to get crushed. But I bet you could survive that way.

Mike B

I wonder if stampede events are a game theoretic problem (each individual is locally optimizing creating a prisoner's dilemma) or if it is an externality generated by asymmetric information. To support the latter I have heard that the part of the group applying the fatal pressure are at the periphery of the crowd and do not get either the proper feedback about the damage their actions are causing.

The people who panic and "cause" the fatal injuries are usually justified as they are being crushed by the flood of unaware people at the periphery of the crowd. I am not sure it would be reasonable to expect people to allow themselves to be crushed in the interests of not starting a wider panic.

AaronS

I think the driving force to in some stampedes is the natural instinct to "do something" (in this case flee) from a perceived threat.

The reason that others are swept up is not just because of the move of bodies, I don't think, but because there is a contagion of fear. When someone starts frantically moving one way, he/she bumps into people who, not knowing what threat (if any) is behind it all, seek to ALSO protect themselves from the issue at hand--and, thus, also begin moving away from the direction of the perceived threat.

Now there are two people caught up in it, and every moment, it grows exponentially, until everyone is running.

Sometimes, it's just that the people at the back, feeling a "give" in the crowd (e.g., a gate opens or breaks down), simply begin moving forward, too far away from the carnage to realize that their actions are killing people to the front.

In any case, I was stunned to find that people die standing up! Wow.

Lastly, it seems that IF one is caught in such a crush, to try to turn sideways, as that may be the only way to continue breathing.

Read more...

frankenduf

anyone who's been in times square new years eve or at a popular free concert knows the thrill and fear of crowd physics trumping freedom of individual movement- definitely the safest places in NYC crowds are along the side of a building or far away from the roadblock- mosh pits exploit crowd physics when the wiseguys in the back yell "push" and the crowd miraculously and inexorably crushes forward, whether u want 2 or not- in fact, i think mosh pit aficianados may have the best crowd survival techniques, as you learn how to avoid falling down in many different contorted states- also, i think they point the way for the best tactic of all, crowd surfing- that is, in a crushable crowd, the best way to survive may be to vault on top and ride the tide- this is what concert crowds do when people pass out, so as not to get crushed or dehydrated, the person is 'passed along' on the top of the crowd

Read more...

Eric M. Jones

Wait a minute....if you die from a stampede while on a pilgrimage to Mecca (the Hajj), you go straight to heaven. Death is welcomed as the doorway to Heaven.

If someone sets from his home as a Pilgrim and then dies, he is granted the reward of a Pilgrim till the Day of Resurrection.
[Prophet Muhammad, s.a.w.]

Instruction for going to Mecca include wearing identification so you body can be identified later. Death by stampede (and dehyrdation) is commonplace.

Drill-Baby-Drill Drill Team

In a Crowd Stampede, It's Survival of the Thickest.

Drill-Baby-Drill Drill Team

It may resemble surviving an avalanche. Being crushed and suffocated by tons of snow.

There are survival techniques involving curling up in fetal position and covering your face and airway with your hands forming a air pocket.

We need an emergency survival 'bubble'.

Useful Perverted Trait: Ironically intense overwhelming body odor may have a protective evolutionary role maintaining our personal space. The incontinent guy on the subway always gets a wide bearth.

Ali

David L - as someone who has been caught up in a similar situation elsewhere (thank God nobody was killed), the drop and cover technique is one of the very worst things you can do. There's no air down there, no way to see what is happening, no way to stop yourself being knocked over, no way to get back up, no way to stop people falling over you (and they will fall on top of you, not just over you). If you go down, it's a strong possiblity that you will not get back up again.

Brian warden

@ Matt: re "hijacked" evolutionary adaptations, the instinct to consume every calorie one can get a hold of comes to mind; probably a wise strategy in our ancestral past (and in many parts of the world still wise) but one that now causes more harm than good. And until being lean equates with better reproductive success, it is an instinct/behaviour that we will probably posess for a very long time.

JBJ

Agree with Ali that drop and cover is a one way ticket with a destination you'd rather not reach.

People will fall on top of you, and as someone who has been at the bottom of a celebration where players for some reason decide to create a human version of the snake pit, I can tell you its a terrible feeling.

You do feel crushed, you have no way out, doesn't matter if its in a fetal or crouched position, the weight will crumble you.

Your only hope is that the people on top of you get off.

bulletproofcourier

How about spraying a can of bear spray in a circle above your head? That might get people moving away from you.

Deal with the consequences later, at least you're still alive.

Eric M. Jones

I'd wager the fetal position is the way to go. The deaths are caused by people being squeezed horizonally, not by weight on top says the article. Besides, that's where the cool air is. The heat and smoke go towards the ceiling.

John

This is one possible reason for the triumph of Henry V at Agincourt - the fact that the lay of the land and the defensive position of the English made the French pack themselves so tightly that they could not even swing their swords. Eventually a lot of them must have been trampled.

Hannah

People advocating duck-and-cover or the fetal position in a crowd crush situation may be discounting the overall movement of the crowd. Yes, people are packed together tightly, but drop something on the ground and a few minutes later you almost certainly won't be standing on it. As slight pockets open up or people shove in a direction, the entire group has to accommodate that movement. If you're low or on the ground, the people around you are going to have to move with the tide no matter what, but you'll be unable to. I've found that one of the most effective ways to stay safe is to try to rally those around you to not bend so much with the shoving; that sort of movement tends to amplify itself and people are much more panicky than if they are standing (relatively) quietly.