Beauty Pays is Out! Bring Your Questions for Dan Hamermesh

Beauty Pays is out!! (Princeton University Press, 2011, available from the Press, or either hardbound or Kindle version). Its central point is that beauty affects outcomes in markets because it is scarce.  It details how these effects function, how large they are, and what they imply about a wide array of markets.

It includes relevant jokes, songs, etc., lots of pictures but no graphs. Despite a “chatty” tone the discussion of beauty illustrates ideas comprising almost half of an introductory micro course.

It raises a wide array of issues and questions. I’m happy to answer any questions that Freakonomics readers might have, so please ask away in the comments section below!

Here’s the table of contents:

Preface

Part I. Background to Beauty

Chapter 1. The Economics of Beauty

Chapter 2. In the Eye of the Beholder
Definitions of Beauty
Why Do Beauty Standards Matter?
How Do We Measure Human Beauty?
Do Observers Agree on Beauty?
Does Beauty Differ by Gender, Race or Age? What Makes You Beautiful?
Can We Become More Beautiful?
The Stage is Set

Part II. Beauty on the Job: What and Why

Chapter 3. Beauty and the Worker
The Central Questions
How Can Beauty Affect Earnings?
How Much More Do Good-Looking People Make?
Is Beauty the Real Cause?
Why Are Beauty Effects Smaller Among Women?
Do Beauty Effects Differ by Race?
Do Beauty Effects Differ by Age?
Compensating the Beauty-Damaged Worker?
Looks Matter for Workers

Chapter 4. Beauty in Specific Occupations
Beauty and Choosing an Occupation
How Big Are Beauty Effects Where Beauty Might Matter?
How Big Are Beauty Effects Where Beauty Might Not Matter?
Sorting by Beauty

Chapter 5. Beauty and the Employer
The Puzzles
Do Good-Looking Employees Raise Sales?
How Does Beauty Affect Profits?
How Can Companies Pay for Beauty and Survive?
Do Companies with Better-Looking CEOs Perform Better?
Beauty Helps Companies—Probably

Chapter 6. Lookism or Productive Beauty, and Why?
What the Beauty Effect Means
How Can Beauty Effects Be Discrimination?
How Can Beauty Be Socially Productive?
What are the Sources of Beauty Effects?
What Is the Direct Evidence on the Sources?
The Importance of Beauty

Part III. Beauty in Love, Loans and Law

Chapter 7. Beauty in Markets for Friends, Family and Funds
Beyond the Labor Market
How Is Beauty Exchanged?
How Does Beauty Affect Group Formation?
How Does Beauty Affect Dating?
How Does Beauty Affect Marriage?
Could There Be a Market for Beautiful Children?
Does Beauty Matter When You Borrow?
Trading Beauty in Unexpected Places

Chapter 8. Legal Protection for the Ugly
Fairness and Public Policy
What Kinds of Protection Are Possible?
How Have Existing Policies Been Used?
Is It Possible to Protect the Ugly?
What Justifies Protecting the Ugly?
What Justifies Not Protecting the Ugly?
What Is an Appropriate Policy?
Protecting the Ugly in the Near Future

Part IV, Chapter 9. Prospects for the Looks-Challenged
The Beauty Conundrum
Are Beautiful People Happier?
What Will Be Beautiful? What Should Be?
What Can Society Do?
What Can You Do If You’re Bad-Looking?


James

Something I've always wondered: Do attractive people show up later to meetings / events / interviews etc.? That is my intuition but has anyone ever studied it?

Skip

Well, the only bit I need to read is chapter 9, "Prospects for the Looks-Challenged". :)

BL1Y

(Just ordered your book, so all I've read is what's available in the Amazon preview.)

On pp 35-36, you say that we're basically stuck with the hand nature has dealt us, even with cosmetics, surgery, etc. Is this only in regards to facial beauty? It would seem that from the neck down, there is much more room for improvement (or to let yourself go).

Quin

How can we (individually and corporately) resist this economic force, and how can we best train our children to resist it?

AaronS

Because I am on the distant end of the beauty spectrum--the low end, alas!--I think it likely that jealousy, self-loathing, and perhaps bitterness at my lot, has caused me to play hardball when beautiful people show up.

A beautiful woman is my manager? Obviously, the tramp slept her way to the top. Or, if not that, she at least used her looks to flirt her way to the top!

A beautiful woman is my waitress? I redouble my guard so that she can't get a bigger tip out of me just because she's good looking. (I mean, really, guys, do we think that a 25% tip will cause her to fall into our arms, beg to bear our children, and the such??? Maybe us guys aren't just not good looking...maybe were stupid, as well.)

Silly men will always have a weak spot for a "pretty little thing." No wonder many of the people who do well in real estate sales are beautiful women. I'm a little silly myself, I'm afraid. I married a girl 13 years my junior. In retrospect, I think it was somehow self-affirming for me, a very below-average looking guy, to parade around a cute little 21-year-old.

In a way, just as women USED to have to work twice as hard to get as much recognition as men, the pretty ones have rebalanced the playing field by having to work less to get what they want.

MY QUESTION: I don't want to know how to even the playing field. I want to know how to UTTERLY DEFEAT pretty people--and to do it without having to work harder or be smarter. I know the answer probably has to do with having photos of the boss in a compromising position, but maybe you have another path to success.

From looking at Dubner's and Levitt's pictures, I know they want to know this too!

Read more...

Eddie

I'm curious about self-awareness of beauty. We're often aware of our competency in many skills and physical traits. Someone who is tall is tall; a great typist knows by their high WPM. There is of ten said to be a type of person who is beautiful "and knows it." Are these people more apt to leverage the advantages beauty brings, or is it an inherent value booster in all who have it? Two equivalent fast typists in the same job would hypothetically perform the same. What about two equivalently attractive people, but one is less aware of their relative attractiveness?

AaronS

Us ugly guys could exploit the "American Idol Loophole"--you know, where grossly untalented people think they can really sing? Maybe there are incredibly beautiful women who think they look terrible...and we could make their day by marrying them despite their terrible "shortcoming." We'd be heroes in their eyes!

Steve S.

Have you noticed any ways that beauty is a double edged sword?

Bill James had a good statement on this topic in "Moneyball" by Michael Lewis, where he equates a potential blessing as a possible bane: (paraphrased) "A pitcher's velocity on his fastball, is like looks on a girl. It matters but its not everything". I took this to mean that while you maybe gifted in one area, in this case velocity/attractiveness, it may lead to short comings elsewhere - pitcher's accuracy or a girl's personality.

Tg3

Does Hamermesh have to give the Freak blog a cut of sales to have this book 'advertisement' appear at the top of the blog for the day (tell me it isn't longer than a day!) i.e. Featured Post?

Maybe there is normally a featured post that stays at the top for a day. This is the first one that I have noticed.

pinkbunnyhat7

The history of what defines beauty would be interesting to know, as well as the gender gap in good looks. Men can look plain and not be criticized, while plain women are told to get makeovers.

BL1Y

"There are no ugly women, only lazy ones."

Maybe plain men aren't told to get makeovers because no one thinks there's any hope for them anyways.

Leon Y

I hope i am not too late in commenting
Here in the Uk, this book is not available yet, I've only been able to read whats been posted around the internet by the author.

I want to talk about a very controversial evolutionary psychologist who has published a blog post called "Beautiful people are more intelligent"
Here are the links to two of his articles. I'll some up his assertions.
http://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/the-scientific-fundamentalist/200903/beautiful-people-are-more-intelligent-i
http://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/the-scientific-fundamentalist/200904/beautiful-people-are-more-intelligent-ii

Heres a quote.
the association between intelligence and physical attractiveness may emerge from the process of assortative mating. If more intelligent men are more desirable to women than less intelligent men, because they achieve higher status, at least in the modern environment, and if physically more attractive women are more desirable to men than physically less attractive women, then there should be assortative mating of intelligent men and beautiful women, and of less intelligent men and less beautiful women. Because both intelligence and physical attractiveness are heritable, such assortative mating should create an extrinsic (non-causal) correlation between intelligence and physical attractiveness in the next generation. Children of intelligent men and attractive women should simultaneously be intelligent and beautiful, and children of less intelligent men and less attractive women should simultaneously be less intelligent and less attractive.

and in a later blog post.
http://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/the-scientific-fundamentalist/201012/beautiful-people-really-are-more-intelligent

"the association between physical attractiveness and intelligence is stronger among men than among women"

I notice in an article written by the author, he states that the income gap for men differing in physical attractiveness is wider than with women. This associates well with the above find.

Could it be that attractive people make more money partially because of their good looks but more so because they are more intelligent?

Thanks

Read more...

Leon Y

I forgot to add I have seen studies claiming that more attractive men were more likely to be hired, but the opposite was true of women, possibly because the admin and recruitment departments of many firms have a higher proportion of female staff who may be jealous at another womans beauty. Could this also add to the disparity in the effect on income of beauty by gender?

Sorry if you've already answered this in detail in your book.

The Regular Joe

but what happens when it seems everybody's TOO

The Regular Joe

let me finish..
what happens when it seems everybody's TOO good looking
http://theregjoe.blogspot.com/2010/10/everybody-is-just-too-good-looking.html

Andreas Moser

Attractive people may be more successful, but hot chicks are also dumber, and here I explain WHY: http://andreasmoser.wordpress.com/2011/04/07/why-hot-girls-are-dumb/

Student

Does your data set include other countries or does it stay in the United States, Thanks!

Amanda

Does beauty matter more than race?