More People Are Quitting Their Jobs. How Good of a Sign Is That?

Fact: in September, we put out an hour-long Freakonomics Radio podcast called “The Upside of Quitting.”

Fact: in September, more Americans quit their jobs than in any month since Nov., 2008.

Coincidence?

Actually, it’s not even a coincidence. The podcast was out on Sept. 30; the resignations (2 million of them) covered the month of September.

That said, more resignations would seem to indicate an improving economy. From Time:

According to a recent survey by job-search site Snagajob, 44% of respondents who quit in the past year did so believing they would find a better opportunity elsewhere, up from 31% the year before.

Why, you might wonder, is Time citing Snagajob rather than a government source? And should we believe those numbers?

Here’s what former Labor Secretary Robert Reich told me in an interview for the quit radio episode:

No, the government doesn’t have good data on this. The Bureau of Labor Statistics collects a lot of data as does the Commerce Department on jobs, but it’s very difficult to tell why people quit. That’s a subjective issue. Are you quitting because you hate your job? Are you quitting because you’re forced to leave? Are you quitting because you have a better job possibility? Some people are not completely candid about why they’re quitting to begin with, and it’s just a very murky area. These days when the economy is still bad, struggling to get out of the gravitational pull of the Great Recession, most people who leave their jobs are still not leaving because they have great, wonderful opportunities elsewhere. They are leaving for most of the time, most instances, particularly if they’re in the bottom two-thirds of the wage ladder, they’re leaving because they have no choice, their employer is basically kicking them out.

The fact is that unemployment is starting to drop; some commentators aren’t cheered.

Leave A Comment

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

 

COMMENTS: 15

View All Comments »
  1. JPB says:

    This might be older, public employees. Government workers are reading the writing on the wall. A lot are getting out now with their pensions intact knowing that if they wait longer, they’ll likely lose. A lot of new contracts are giving back on salaries, which would lower last-3-year calculations. So it pays for people in the 50-60 range to get out now and perhaps move into private employment.

    Thumb up 5 Thumb down 1
    • Jeff says:

      …while collecting their pension. Ugh. This country.

      [WORDPRESS HASHCASH] The poster sent us ’0 which is not a hashcash value.

      Thumb up 6 Thumb down 6
      • Steve O says:

        Their pension that they were promised when they signed up 35 years ago… Greedy bastards, wanting their contract obligations.

        Well-loved. Like or Dislike: Thumb up 14 Thumb down 7
      • J1 says:

        “Their pension that they were promised when they signed up 35 years ago”

        I was promised a pension too. When my company declared bankruptcy, it vanished in an instant. It can happen to government employees too. In fact they’re in a worse spot, because their employer can just say “sorry”, without going through the banktruptcy process. For younger readers, some advice: acquire the discipline to save while you’re young, and don’t EVER voluntarily agree to a defined benefit pension. Get that money up front, so it can’t be flushed down the drain by some Magna Cum Laude Harvard grad who, though really, really good at going to school, is nevertheless too stupid and incompetent to run a lemonade stand, much less a large corporation. Not that I have an axe to grind…

        As to the people quitting their jobs, it seems unlikely there’s a single source. A lot of students working summer jobs quit in September, many may be government employees bailing out as JPB notes, and there is always going to be a cohort whose abilities are simply in high demand regardless of the condition of the economy. It sounds like it might be the government employees, as government employment seems to be decreasing.

        That assumes, of course, that these stats are real, and not something that actually should have fallen into the toilet.

        Thumb up 2 Thumb down 0
  2. Andreas Moser says:

    I quit my office job in London in November to move to the sunny island of Malta for the winter: http://andreasmoser.wordpress.com/2011/11/13/leaving-london-moving-to-malta/ – one of the best decisions in my life!

    Thumb up 2 Thumb down 3
  3. Bobby Calise says:

    Very interesting topic…I guess if people are leaving out of choice instead of desperation, it’s a good thing. I actually blogged about it recently here.: http://bobbycalise.wordpress.com/2011/11/09/how-to-quit-your-job-during-a-recession-and-live-to-tell-about-it/

    Thumb up 1 Thumb down 1
  4. Vincent says:

    I quit my job with a software startup because the company is run by lousy human beings. No regrets.

    Thumb up 5 Thumb down 1
  5. CC says:

    I left my job in November for another job with a 50% pay increase, though I am most likely not typical.

    Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0
  6. Allen says:

    I am always amazed that the same people who think a 1 or 2 percent uptick is a great leading indicator seem to be able to ignore a 1 or 2 percent drop as “inconsequential”. If it’s cause for joy when it goes up that much it’s a cause for equal worry. We need to create close to 200,000 NEW jobs every month just to place the people entering the workforce for their first job. Plus we have to create enough jobs to put the people laid off (nonsense, they were fired) back to work. So far what the experts cite as cause for hope hasn’t come anywhere close to those numbers.

    Thumb up 2 Thumb down 0
  7. Hilary Louise says:

    Benzinga covered this post over at (http://www.benzinga.com/news/11/12/2177816/ongoing-developments-in-the-unemployment-conundrum), pulling in Market Watch’s Brett Arends’ recent jobs commentary as well (http://www.marketwatch.com/story/10-reasons-the-crisis-isnt-over-2011-11-29).

    They also pulled in Mr. Hamermesh’s previous post on Freakonomics (http://www.freakonomics.com/2011/12/02/the-trouble-behind-the-new-unemployment-data/).

    The synthesis on Benzinga is good, but I want to posit to all of you this question — what do you think of the author’s final analysis? Legit?

    “One way or another, work is something fundamental to the human experience; given the nature of human economic activity, it makes sense that the market would offer individuals the ability to work; if the market is not offering individuals the ability to work, then something is seriously wrong systemically.”

    Thumb up 1 Thumb down 0
    • Brian says:

      In response ^^ I think that Marco’s argument of global unemployment as a youth discussion and systemic flaw/context is good, but not the root.

      I don’t know that levying taxes is the answer but I do like his discussion. More inclined to Arends all in all.

      Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0
  8. Travis says:

    What if it’s not analyzed from the point of view of how many different / attractive / possible job opportunities are out there, but instead from the point of view that there are so many workers and such a glut of recruitment that the jubs people are currently holding are bad enough that people would rather be unemployed or searching.

    Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0